150 days on Market

209 Bay Street St, Shanty Bay, Ontario L0L 2L0

Detached
5
5 + 2
~3290 sqft
$4,999,900
Get pre-qualifiedPowered by nesto
Detached
5
5 + 2
~3290 sqft

Contact us about this property

Call

Highlights

Property Estimate

Days on market150 days

Estimated valueNot available

Price/Sqft$1,519/sqft

Monthly cost

Open Calculator

Description

Lakefront Paradise in Shanty Bay! Discover the ultimate waterfront retreat on the serene shores of Lake Simcoe. Tucked away on a peaceful dead-end street in the charming village of Shanty Bay, this exceptional property offers 200 feet of prime south-facing waterfront with crystal-clear, deep waters—perfect for boating and swimming. This expansive estate features a main cottage, a guest house, and an over-the-garage bunkie, totaling 12 bedrooms, 3 kitchens, and 8 bathrooms—ideal for large families, entertaining, or rental opportunities. Enjoy breathtaking lake views from most principal rooms across all dwellings. Outdoor amenities include a private concrete patio by the water, a marine railway system leading to a covered boat slip, and a spacious deck above, offering spectacular views of Kempenfelt Bay. The park-like setting, surrounded by mature trees, ensures unmatched privacy while keeping you close to modern conveniences—just 10 minutes from Barrie’s amenities and Royal Victoria Hospital, and only an hour from Toronto. Boating enthusiasts will love the short ride to Friday Harbour’s restaurants, and nature lovers can easily access the Simcoe Loop Trail for walking or biking. The main cottage exudes classic charm, featuring a stone fireplace, wood floors, a cozy family room, a Muskoka room with lake views, and a unique third-level loft. Additional highlights include parking for 10+ cars and an in-floor heated garage. Whether you enjoy this stunning property as it is or explore future severance potential, this is a rare opportunity to own a slice of lakefront paradise.


Property Details

StyleTwo Story
ViewLake, Water
Age of property-
SqFt~3290 SqFt
Lot Size-
Parking Spaces12
MLS ®Number40703719
Community NameOro-Medonte
Data SourceITSO
Listing byRE/MAX Hallmark Chay Realty Brokerage

Features

Heating: Forced Air, Natural Gas
Cooling: Central Air
Basement: Full, Unfinished

Second Floor

Bedroom

4.88 x 4.27

Hardwood Floor

Bedroom

3.66 x 3.66

hardwood floor / walkout to balcony/deck

Bedroom

3.96 x 3.35

Hardwood Floor

Bathroom

2.01 x 2.49

3-Piece


Features

Septic Tank

Parking

Garage spaces 2

Garage type -

Other parking spaces 10

Total parking spaces 12


Property History

Mar 5, 2025
ListedActive
$4,999,900
150 days on market
history photo preview45
Listing by itso®
Property listed by RE/MAX Hallmark Chay Realty Brokerage, Brokerage
Agent Banner Image
Interested in this property?Get in touch to get the inside scoop.

Market Data - Oro-Medonte

Geo Zone Map ThumbnailOro-Medonte

Strong Buyer's Market

View Market Data

Detached house - for the past 30 days

Buyer's market Seller's market

Avg. Days on Market

Past 30 days

46 days

Compared to

2024

45 days

2023

42 days

2022

19 days

New Listings

Past 30 days

104 listings

Compared to

2024

109 listings

2023

91 listings

2022

101 listings

Units sold

Past 30 days

36 units

Compared to

2024

26 units

2023

32 units

2022

18 units

Median Sold Price

Past 30 days

$1,080,000

Compared to

2024

$1,120,000

2023

$1,067,500

2022

$961,750


Population and Demographics

Overview

Total population 25308
Average household income $149,316

Age (%)

0 to 19
21%
20 to 34
15%
35 to 49
18%
50 to 64
25%
65 and plus
21%

Household composition (%)

Single family
78%
Single person
19%
Multi person
3%
Multi family
1%

Mother tongue (%)

English
93%
Others
5%
French
2%

House tenancy (%)

Owners
92%
Renters
8%

What’s nearby?Essentials within 5 km

Local Logic

Transportation Scores

Estimated Budget