Home with vinyl exterior material, building for 5368 Menzie St, Niagara Falls Ontario L2E 2V8
2 days on Market

5368 Menzie St, Niagara Falls, Ontario L2E 2V8

Townhouse
-
5
~4128 sqft
$1,199,900
Get pre-qualifiedPowered by nesto
Townhouse
-
5
~4128 sqft

Contact us about this property

Call

Highlights

Estimated ValueNot available

Price/Sqft$290/sqft

Est. Mortgage$5,153/mo

Tax Amount (2024)$4,896/yr

Days On Market2 days


Description

Own a Rare Piece of Niagaras History - Endless Possibilities Await! Step into a truly one-of-a-kind estate where timeless elegance meets modern convenience. This captivating residence, currently configured as a spacious single-family home, offers the flexibility to be effortlessly converted back into a 5-unit apartment building making it an exceptional opportunity for investors, developers, or those dreaming of a distinctive B&B or Airbnb venture. Boasting over 4,000 sq. ft. of living space, the home features soaring 12' ceilings, original hardwood floors, 8 doors, intricate cove moulding, plaster trim, a grand staircase, and a stunning solid marble fireplace mantel classic architectural details that exude charm and character at every turn. Located just minutes from Niagara Falls Premier Entertainment District, this property also offers ample parking and unmatched access to local attractions. Over the past 26 years, nearly every major system has been thoughtfully updated, including: High-efficiency furnace & AC Newer windows & exterior doors 200-amp electrical panel, rebuilt back porch, updated fencing, and more. (Please refer to the full upgrade sheet for a complete list of improvements.) Whether you're seeking a distinctive home, a smart income property, or a hospitality venture, this rare gem delivers both historic beauty and modern reliability. The adjacent property at 120 Bridge St. is also available for purchase unlocking even more potential. Schedule your private tour today and envision the possibilities!


Property Details

StyleResidential Income
View-
Age of property1850
SqFt~4128 SqFt
Lot Size10,579 SqFt(109.95 x 96.22)
Parking Spaces10
MLS ®Number40734355
Community NameElgin
Data SourceITSO
Listing byRE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd.

Features

Heating: Forced Air, Natural Gas
Cooling: Central Air
Basement: Full, Unfinished

Features

Lot size: 10,579 SqFt
Pool: In Ground
Sewer (Municipal)

Parking

Garage spaces -

Garage type -

Total parking spaces 10


Property History

Jun 18, 2025
ListedActive
$1,199,900
2 days on market
history photo preview45
Listing by itso®
Property listed by RE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd., Brokerage
Agent Banner Image
Interested in this property?Get in touch to get the inside scoop.

Market Data - Elgin

Geo Zone Map ThumbnailElgin

Strong Buyer's Market

View Market Data

Townhouse - for the past 30 days

Buyer's market Seller's market

Avg. Days on Market

Past 30 days

35 days

Compared to

2024

0 day

2023

7 days

2022

7 days

New Listings

Past 30 days

7 listings

Compared to

2024

2 listings

2023

5 listings

2022

2 listings

Units sold

Past 30 days

1 unit

Compared to

2024

0 unit

2023

1 unit

2022

1 unit

Median Sold Price

Past 30 days

$360,000

Compared to

2023

$638,000

2022

$575,000


Population and Demographics

Overview

Total population 9664
Average household income $80,133

Age (%)

50 to 64
23%
65 and plus
22%
20 to 34
20%
35 to 49
18%
0 to 19
17%

Household composition (%)

Single family
49%
Single person
43%
Multi person
7%
Multi family
0%

Mother tongue (%)

English
86%
Others
6%
Italian
3%
French
2%
Spanish
2%

House tenancy (%)

Owners
54%
Renters
46%

What’s nearby?Essentials within 5 km

Local Logic

Transportation Scores

Estimated Budget